Sales Representative Interview Scorecard Template

A sales interview scorecard rates the things that actually close deals: asking good questions, explaining value simply, handling "no" and staying honest. This template covers six areas for telesales and field sales representatives, with role-play questions so you hear how candidates sell instead of how they describe themselves.

What this role asks of people

Sales candidates are often good at interviews, because talking well is part of the job. That makes unstructured interviews risky: a confident story can hide a candidate who never asks the customer a question or who promises things the product cannot do.

The fix is to make candidates sell during the interview. Short role-plays, the same for everyone, show discovery, objection handling and honesty far better than "tell me about yourself".

Before you score: must-have checks

  • Accepts the pay structure, including the share that depends on commission or targets.
  • Can cover the territory or shift: travel, a driving licence if the role needs one, or the call hours for telesales.
  • Speaks the language your customers use at the level the role needs.
  • Has no conflict with a current employer that would stop them selling your product, such as a non-compete they mention.

A recruiter confirms these with the candidate. A "no" starts a conversation; it is never an automatic rejection.

The scorecard

Ask every candidate the same questions, then score each area from 1 to 5 using the descriptions. The weights show how much each area counts.

Use this template

Print a blank copy or save it as a PDF, open it in Excel, or paste it into Word or Google Docs, then edit it to fit your role.

  1. 1.Discovery and listening

    20% of the score

    Asks questions to understand what the customer needs before recommending anything.

    Ask

    • Role-play: I am a customer who just called about [your product]. Start the conversation.
    • What do you need to know about a customer before you recommend something?
    1, weak
    Starts pitching straight away. Asks no questions, or only closed ones.
    3, meets the bar
    Asks two or three useful questions, then moves to a general pitch.
    5, strong
    Asks open questions, listens to the answers, and shapes the recommendation around what the customer said.
  2. 2.Explaining value clearly

    20% of the score

    Explains why the product helps this customer, in simple words and in a short time.

    Ask

    • In 30 seconds, tell me why I should choose [your product] over doing nothing.
    • Explain one product you sold or know well to someone who has never heard of it.
    1, weak
    Lists features or uses jargon. Runs long. No link to the customer’s need.
    3, meets the bar
    Clear but generic. One benefit is linked to the customer.
    5, strong
    Short and concrete. Links the benefit to what the customer said earlier and checks it landed.
  3. 3.Handling objections and rejection

    20% of the score

    Treats "no" and "too expensive" as questions to understand, and keeps going after a bad day.

    Ask

    • I tell you, "It is too expensive, I will think about it." What do you say?
    • Tell me about a week when you heard "no" a lot. What kept you going?
    1, weak
    Drops the price at once, argues, or gives up. No real example of rejection.
    3, meets the bar
    Asks one question about the objection and offers an answer. The example is general.
    5, strong
    Finds out what is behind the objection, answers it honestly, and agrees a next step. Gives a specific example of bouncing back.
  4. 4.Target drive and self-management

    15% of the score

    Works towards a number, tracks progress and plans the day without being chased.

    Ask

    • Tell me about a target you had, at work, in studies or in sport. How did you track it?
    • How would you plan your day if you had 60 calls or 8 visits to make?
    1, weak
    Cannot name a target or how they followed it.
    3, meets the bar
    Names a target and roughly how it went, with little about how they tracked it.
    5, strong
    Gives a number, how they tracked it week by week, and what they changed when they were behind.
  5. 5.Honesty with customers

    15% of the score

    Will not overpromise to close a sale, because returns and complaints cost more than the deal.

    Ask

    • A customer asks for something our product cannot do. What do you say?
    • Tell me about a time you could have made a sale by bending the truth. What did you do?
    1, weak
    Would say yes and "sort it out later", or sees no problem with it.
    3, meets the bar
    Would tell the truth but has no plan for keeping the customer.
    5, strong
    Tells the truth, offers what the product can do or another option, and keeps the relationship.
  6. 6.Motivation and fit with the pay model

    10% of the score

    Wants this kind of sales job and understands how they will be paid.

    Ask

    • How do you feel about pay that is part fixed and part commission?
    • Why sales, and why this product?
    1, weak
    Wants a fixed salary only, or has no reason for choosing sales.
    3, meets the bar
    Accepts commission and has a general reason for applying.
    5, strong
    Is motivated by the commission model and gives a specific reason this product or market interests them.

How to score and decide

Run the role-plays the same way for everyone: same customer, same objection, same time limit. Score each area straight after the answer and note the words the candidate used.

Weighted score: multiply each score by its weight, add them up and divide by 100. You get a score out of 5.

Set the bar before you start, for example "3.5 or above, with at least 3 in honesty". A low honesty score deserves a conversation, whatever the total.

The scorecard informs the decision. A person on your team makes it.

A filled-in scorecard

Illustrative example

Candidate B, applying for a telesales role selling internet packages

CriterionWeightScore
Discovery and listening20%4 / 5
Explaining value clearly20%4 / 5
Handling objections and rejection20%3 / 5
Target drive and self-management15%4 / 5
Honesty with customers15%5 / 5
Motivation and fit with the pay model10%3 / 5
Weighted score3.9 / 5

Good discovery questions and a clear 30-second pitch. Dropped the price too early in the objection role-play, so the manager scored it 3 and planned coaching on objection handling if hired. Candidate B and the product are invented for this example.

Common mistakes

  • Hiring the most confident talker without testing how they sell.
  • Changing the role-play from candidate to candidate.
  • Scoring "would be great with customers" instead of what the candidate actually did in the role-play.
  • Ignoring honesty because the candidate scored high everywhere else.
  • Asking only about past numbers that you cannot check, instead of watching them sell.

Common questions

What should a sales interview scorecard include?
Discovery, explaining value, objection handling, target drive, honesty and motivation, with weights, the same role-plays for everyone and clear descriptions of a 1, a 3 and a 5.
Should I use role-plays in a first-round sales interview?
Yes, short ones. A two-minute role-play with a fixed scenario tells you more than a long conversation about past results, and it is fair because everyone gets the same one.
Does this work for field sales and telesales?
Yes. Keep the criteria and change the role-play setting: a phone call for telesales, a visit or a shop counter for field sales.
Can Gahiz run the role-play for me?
Gahiz runs structured voice interviews where the AI interviewer asks the same questions and follow-ups to every candidate, and your team gets a scorecard linked to the answers. You choose the questions; your team decides who moves forward.

Interview questions for this role

More scorecard templates

Related hiring guides

Sources

  1. US Office of Personnel Management, Structured Interviews: A Practical Guide (2008)